« Mmm, Nike Juice. | Main | I'm a Monster »

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83455f5ee69e200d8345b395569e2

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Applejack:

» Apple's TV ads are a rip-off of Postal Service video from Boing Boing
Watch the side-by-side video of these two commercials by Apple and a Postal Service video and marvel at how similar they are. Just co-incidence? Link (thanks, Ben!)... [Read More]

» Intel Ad a clone? from macsig
Some astute viewers have noticed that the new Intel ad from Apple looks very similar to a music video from the Postal Service. Watch them side by side and judge for yourself.... [Read More]

» Apple Commercial Controversy: Round II from O'Grady's PowerPage
The Spunker has a blog entry calling out Apple for their latest television commerical. Apparently the new TV ad is almost an exact copy of a television commercial by the U.S. Postal Service. First Lugz, now the Postal Service? You've... [Read More]

» Apple och Intel bråkar + Apple har snott reklamidén from Researcher
Apple har lyckats att göra sin nya processorleverantör upprörda på grund av sin nya reklamfilm. I spoten förklarar Apple att Intel-processorerna blivit fria i samband med att de hamnat i Macintosh-datorerna. Helt enligt det koncept som Apple kört ända... [Read More]

» Apples-2-Appl3s from dotguy
Here is a link to yet another ad for Apple products that appears very, very similar to a previously produced work by someone else, presumably someone other than Apple. View the side-by-side, shot-by-shot comparison in Applejack on The S... [Read More]

» Apple sly from Screenhead
We're still getting mail correcting us, despite having amended this post about 1/2 hour after we posted it, so we're re-organizing it ass to front, with the update at... [Read More]

» Apples TV Commercial from pdxsurreal blog
TheSpunker - by Ben Popken. Published by Gattaca, Inc.: Applejack OKI love Apple, but watch the side by side comparison (theres a link on the Gattaca, Inc. blog page) I produce video, and am definitely inspired by others wor... [Read More]

» Generic drugs viagra cialis levitra and more. from Drug levitra.
Levitra dosage. Cialis levitra. Levitra. [Read More]

» Milf sex stories. from Kinky milf hunter ambur crazy orgy group sex.
Hot milf having sex with period. Reality sex milf. Milf sex. Nude milf sex. Free milf sex pictures. Sex milf. [Read More]

» Phentermine adipex. from Phentermine and adipex tablet online.
Generic adipex online. Adipex. Adipex p free prescription. Adipex fed ex. Adipex 37.5 cheap without rx. Adipex without a prescription. [Read More]

» Tramadol. from Tramadol cod.
Tramadol hcl. Tramadol. What is tramadol 93. [Read More]

» Free gay porn. from Free gay porn.
Free asian porn. [Read More]

» Levitra. from Levitra.
Liquid levitra. Levitra free sample. [Read More]

Comments

ChrisJM

Check out the original site to post this video, link below, along with several screen-shots from the videos, showing just how similar they are. The Postal Service's record label has since reported that they were unaware of the Apple Ad, and The Postal Service has now piped in, saying that they're "disappointed" with Apple and the ad agency that made both videos, because they weren't involved in the decision.
http://www.ELITEproductionsWI.com/apple-ps.htm

Travis

it's all very much the same way that the postal service used the napolean dynamite director for their "we will become silhouttes" video. of course the postal service wasn't complain about using similar imagery from a film to sell their cd.

kettle calling pot black.

bernie

Rip off: I'm sold.
But it seems all is well in synergy land. I was on the itunes store today and the such great heights video is PROMINENTLY displayed at the top of the front page (Canadian store). This is not a coincidence. The album has been out for almost 2 years.

So if they didn't buy the rights, at least they are promoting the video.

It is weird however, that they do this AGAIN. I mean they ripped off Eminem and then instead of paying him back, they promoted him in another rip off [of lugz]. And now this. I guess they and/or their ad agencies can do what they damn well please. They are the creative mothership afterall. And what the mothership giveth the mothership can taketh away.

Mr eel

All this rip-off shit is missing the point. The question here is did Apple or their ad agancy ask for the directors to do a shot for shot remake of The Postal Service clip, or did the directors do this of their own accord?

If Apple asked for it, they're foolish. If directors reproduced the clip without telling anyone, Apple have a right to be pissed off. Problem is, we don't know any of this. So just chill uleh.

Erik

Quite inane that most of the trackbacks here mistake The Postal Service music video for an ad for the U.S. Postal Service. Haha. You can edit your mistakes on your respective pages, but you can't edit your trackbacks!

Ben Popken

Assuming your information is correct and its the same director team, Todd, my answer is yes, it's still a ripoff. Though, the onus is on TBWA (the ad agency) and Apple, not the directors. Hey that thing you did was great, do it again but for us. That's unoriginal thinking and that's a crime when your brand position is "Think Different."

todd heyman

It' the same director team. Is it a rip off if they ripped themselves off?

werm

Wow, some people's definition of what's a rip-off is pretty "skewed" (to be polite). Some of these apologists are almost at the "well, they used a camera to shoot it, and people have used cameras before, so it's not a rip-off...". Sheesh!

It's pretty clear that either Apple bought or licensed the rights to the PS footage, or the same director shot both. It's just too similar. There are thousands of ways the same facility could have been shot and edited and post-processed, but it's exactly the same - same lighting, same camera moves, same framing, same editing style, same suited techs handing off disks, and exactly the same framing on many shots (which leads me to believe that Apple licensed it). What's up with apologists, anyway? DO you work in the Apple ad dept?

dooky

Well this alone doesnt constitute a cry of RIPOFF! When u look back at ALL of Apples recent ads and realized they were all ripoffs then u see that something is fishy with apples ad department. the famous black ipod ads being ripped were well crhonicled online as well were the Eminem ads.

grubs

This "Same subject matter" or "Just inspired by" is really lame apologist junk.

The shots are framed the same. They have nothing to do with powers of ten. I can't see a single frame that has the same lighting, angles, wardrobe and framing as either of these pieces to powers of ten. Next to each, they aren't reminiscent of each other or even video of the same type of action as they are a reproduction of specific shots to the greatest detail possible.

These frames that are pulled out side by side are nearly identical shots. Watch the side by side.

Although I have to say the plaigarism isn't nearly as bad as the mac apologists attitude. "You should be proud to have a great company like Apple take your shots."

shriki

I <3 Postal Service.

manuel

who is not seeking for inspiration in other ppl's work? not saying this because i am a mac evangelist, but because it is so normal. most of us do, and i would be honored if such a great company would get its inspiration for such a clip out of my work. and what the others said: chip facilities do look all very similiar.

and it was kinda obvious that the ad-theme for the intelchip introduction would have something to do with chips. so whats the fuzz? :)

ckawalek

Definitely not as much of a rip-off as the Apple Eminem ad vs. the Lugz ad. And hey it's great advertising for Postal Service, everybody wants to see the video.

http://www.macworld.com/news/2005/11/07/lugz/index.php

-Chris

ckawalek

Definitely not as much of a rip-off as the Apple Eminem ad vs. the Lugz ad.

http://www.macworld.com/news/2005/11/07/lugz/index.php

-Chris

Sheik Yerbouti

Yeah, it looks like they both got access to a chip plant and two dramatists (directors) went at it in a similar fashion. I attribute this more to the same production being captured and not a rip off. The angles are different :P

Majken

I wouldn't say it's a rip-off. Rip-off is meant to denote someone that passed someone else's work off as their own. This looks completely intentional, listen to the words of the song, the name of the song is "Such Great Heights" this seems to be the entire message of the apple ad. The reproduced shots are too perfect to be anything other than an intentional 'reference' to the music video. Too perfect for someone trying to "rip-off" someone else's work. Perhaps there is a long version that uses this song as the soundtrack to the commercial?

Ed Knittel

I think "rip-off" is a rather harsh term to use especially if you do not know the arrangement and the agreement that was made with Apple and the director of the Intel ads in regards to the "Such Great Heights" video. Until we know everything I think we should save judgement for later. But, if you'd rather play the game your way, the Postal Service video has ripped off Charles and Ray Eames' "Powers of Ten" http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-5555313278261147278&q=powers+of+ten or maybe you think they were just "influenced". How do you tell the difference again?

Duncan

For all we know it could be the same director!

alfie

not a rip off? What? Timing and design aesthetic alone is enough to show this as a pretty direct rip-off, what is interesting is whether that can be proved in a copyright case.

Total Rip off

Yes, but if you've ever worked in video editing and cinema you would know that camera angles are well thought out and planned. For some of these angles to be EXACTLY the same is a total rip off.

Rezmason

It's too bad that originality is such a difficult thing to gauge these days. Is there any way to guarantee that the makers of the Apple ad were or weren't "inspired" by the music video? And even if they were, how do we measure the amount of creativity that they *did* have?

Spencer Parker

I wouldn't say it is a direct rip-off they both cover the same concept...they are pretty similar...

Not Really

If you've ever worked in a facility producing silicon wafers, you would know that they all appear very similiar.

Kool

Far fetched to say that this is a rip-off!!

The comments to this entry are closed.

Written By

  • Ben Popken
    Send in your tips.